Sprott Gold Bulletin

Paper Tiger

Paper Tiger

After a lot of late-March huffing and puffing in COMEX markets to achieve a month-end close for spot gold below $1,300, trading in physical gold markets proved especially robust during the first week of April. To us, this suggests gold’s sub-$1,300 spot price is destined to be short lived.

A topic of longstanding interest in the precious metals space has been the interplay between paper and physical markets. Paper gold markets are best exemplified by exchanges such as COMEX, which trade high volumes of futures and options contracts, but very little tangible metal. In contrast, the world’s primary markets for physical gold are countries such as China and India, where buyers prefer to take possession of the bullion they are trading.

In our experience, gold price weakness tends to gain momentum in the highly levered (and traditionally gold skeptical) COMEX environment and is reversed by staunch demand in traditional physical markets. In this manner, global physical markets set lows for corrections in paper gold markets. Indeed, in evaluating the role of Western-type futures and options in global gold markets, it is instructive to highlight just how far removed COMEX trading actually is from anything having to do with physical bullion.

In Figure 1, we present annual figures for a few interesting characteristics of COMEX gold futures trading since 2010. From left-to-right in our table, we have listed: a.) annual COMEX gold futures volume in millions-of-contracts; b.) notional physical volume of these contracts in metric tons (tonnes); c.) total tonnage of bullion used in physical settlement of COMEX contracts; and d.) interpolated percentage of COMEX contracts settled physically.

Figure 1. Annual COMEX Trading Statistics, Shanghai Exchange Gold Withdrawals & Indian Gold Imports (2010-Present)

Year  Contract Volume Millions (a.)  Notional Volume Metric Tons (b.) Delivery Tonnage (c.) % Physical Settlement (d.) Shanghai Withdrawals (e.) Indian Import Tonnage (f.)
2010 44.7 138,657 178 0.13% 837 972
2011 49.2 152,956 185 0.12% 1,043 1,073
2012 43.9 136,478 119 0.09% 1,139 976
2013 47.3 147,106 222 0.15% 2,197 834
2014 40.5 126,030 79 0.06% 2,102 788
2015 41.8 130,135 50 0.04% 2,596 955
2016 57.6 179,051 183 0.10% 1,970 584
2017 72.8 226,445 95 0.04% 2,030 891
2018 80.3 249,772 79 0.03% 2,055 782
2019-04-05 18.1 56,398 54 0.10% 318* 116*

Source: Meridian Macro. *2/28/2019

During 2018, COMEX trading volume totaled 80.3 million contracts, or 249,772 tonnes, some 75 times global mine production. Amazingly, during the entire 2018 trading year, the total amount of physical gold utilized to settle expiring contracts was only 79 tonnes or less than 0.03% of traded contracts. For reference, physical bullion withdrawals from the Shanghai Gold Exchange during 2018 totaled 2,055 tonnes (Chinese imports, domestic production and scrap recovery) and Indian gold imports totaled 782 tonnes, together some 36 times COMEX physical deliveries during the year.

Pulling this all together, COMEX trading volumes can distort price trends in physical markets only for short periods, because lack of physical bullion to anchor this paper speculation (combined with perpetual time-value erosion inherent in futures contracts) always yields pricing equilibrium back to intractable inertia of physical stocks.

Indian Ex-Duty Premiums Doubled Last Week: Bullish Sign

Given the negative slant to COMEX gold trading during the week of 3/25/19, we were especially curious to observe how physical markets would respond during the week of 4/1/19. We specifically cite the analysis of John Brimelow (JBGJ LLC) who monitors a wide array of price action in global physical markets on a daily basis. Brimelow pioneered the concept of Indian ex-duty premiums, a measurement of the premium paid by Indian gold importers in excess of the sum of global spot plus Indian import duties. Importantly, importing gold bullion into India currently incurs a duty of 10%, plus 3% sales tax, plus 0.3% in local taxes, for a total of import duty of 13.3%.

Using the median of Reuters A.M. price quotes for India’s five major gold-importing hubs (Mumbai, Ahmedabad, Chennai, Delhi and Jaipur), Brimelow had reported during the six days ended 3/29 that Indian ex-duty premiums had averaged $5.12. Following the COMEX drubbing, however, during the week of 4/1, Indian A.M. ex-duty premiums doubled to $10.05, an unequivocally bullish sign.

To put this in perspective, it is as if Indian gold buyers, who import more bullion than any other country in the world, sent a signal to COMEX gold bears, “Hey, just add $172 (in duties, taxes and premiums ) to the spot price of whatever you want to sell and send it over to us. We’ll take it all!”

This should be fun to watch.


Spot Gold Price
As of Friday Close, 4/5/2019
Closing Price 1 Week %
$1,291.75 -0.04%

Sign-Up Now: 
Insights from Sprott

More on Gold

Important Disclosure

Past performance is no guarantee of future results. You cannot invest directly in an index. Investments, commentary and statements are that of the author and may not be reflective of investments and commentary in other strategies managed by Sprott Asset Management USA, Inc., Sprott Asset Management LP, Sprott Inc., or any other Sprott entity or affiliate. Opinions expressed in this commentary are those of the author and may vary widely from opinions of other Sprott affiliated Portfolio Managers or investment professionals.

This content may not be reproduced in any form, or referred to in any other publication, without acknowledgment that it was produced by Sprott Asset Management LP and a reference to The opinions, estimates and projections (“information”) contained within this content are solely those of Sprott Asset Management LP (“SAM LP”) and are subject to change without notice. SAM LP makes every effort to ensure that the information has been derived from sources believed to be reliable and accurate. However, SAM LP assumes no responsibility for any losses or damages, whether direct or indirect, which arise out of the use of this information. SAM LP is not under any obligation to update or keep current the information contained herein. The information should not be regarded by recipients as a substitute for the exercise of their own judgment. Please contact your own personal advisor on your particular circumstances. Views expressed regarding a particular company, security, industry or market sector should not be considered an indication of trading intent of any investment funds managed by Sprott Asset Management LP. These views are not to be considered as investment advice nor should they be considered a recommendation to buy or sell. SAM LP and/or its affiliates may collectively beneficially own/control 1% or more of any class of the equity securities of the issuers mentioned in this report. SAM LP and/or its affiliates may hold short position in any class of the equity securities of the issuers mentioned in this report. During the preceding 12 months, SAM LP and/or its affiliates may have received remuneration other than normal course investment advisory or trade execution services from the issuers mentioned in this report.

SAM LP is the investment manager to the Sprott Physical Bullion Trusts (the “Trusts”). Important information about the Trusts, including the investment objectives and strategies, purchase options, applicable management fees, and expenses, is contained in the prospectus. Please read the document carefully before investing. Investment funds are not guaranteed, their values change frequently and past performance may not be repeated. This communication does not constitute an offer to sell or solicitation to purchase securities of the Trusts. You will usually pay brokerage fees to your dealer if you purchase or sell units of the Trusts on the Toronto Stock Exchange (“TSX”) or the New York Stock Exchange (“NYSE”). If the units are purchased or sold on the TSX or the NYSE, investors may pay more than the current net asset value when buying units or shares of the Trusts and may receive less than the current net asset value when selling them.

The risks associated with investing in a Trust depend on the securities and assets in which the Trust invests, based upon the Trust’s particular objectives. There is no assurance that any Trust will achieve its investment objective, and its net asset value, yield and investment return will fluctuate from time to time with market conditions. There is no guarantee that the full amount of your original investment in a Trust will be returned to you. The Trusts are not insured by the Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation or any other government deposit insurer. Please read a Trust’s prospectus before investing.

The information contained herein does not constitute an offer or solicitation to anyone in the United States or in any other jurisdiction in which such an offer or solicitation is not authorized or to any person to whom it is unlawful to make such an offer or solicitation. Prospective investors who are not resident in Canada or the United States should contact their financial advisor to determine whether securities of the Funds may be lawfully sold in their jurisdiction.

The information provided is general in nature and is provided with the understanding that it may not be relied upon as, nor considered to be, the rendering or tax, legal, accounting or professional advice. Readers should consult with their own accountants and/or lawyers for advice on their specific circumstances before taking any action.

© 2022 Sprott Inc. All rights reserved.

Sprott uses cookies to understand how you use our website and to improve your experience. This includes personalizing content on our website and third-party websites. To learn more and to manage your advertising preferences, see our Cookie Policy


Important Message

You are now leaving and entering a linked website. Sprott has partnered with ALPS in offering Sprott ETFs. For fact sheets, marketing materials, prospectuses, performance, expense information and other details about the ETFs, you will be directed to the ALPS/Sprott website at

Continue to Sprott Exchange Traded Funds

Important Message

You are now leaving and entering a linked website. Sprott Asset Management is a sub-advisor for several mutual funds on behalf of Ninepoint Partners. For details on these funds, you will be directed to the Ninepoint Partners website at

Continue to Ninepoint Partners

Important Message

You are now leaving and linking to a third-party website. Sprott assumes no liability for the content of this linked site and the material it presents, including without limitation, the accuracy, subject matter, quality or timeliness of the content. The fact that this link has been provided does not constitute an endorsement, authorization, sponsorship by or affiliation with Sprott with respect to the linked site or the material.